Re: Virus thread, the political one.
Originally Posted by
fastupslowdown
so I think the post office should be privatized but this whole raise the price on packaging is a canard.
All for privatizing the postal service. We don't need Saturday delivery. Corporations get subsidized prices to spam the public and cause waste and litter and the services provided are way behind what's available in Europe. In any cases mail could be digitized and sent to us electronically. All for that, but I'm not going to enable a crazy President who is pretending to about fiscal discipline. -Mike G
Couple of things....
Folks often assume that privatization will work because “business is more efficient than government”. That is not necessarily true because
1) Government is not a separate entity it is the populace. So the “inefficiency” is actually valued by the populace but would not be by a corporation. Thus the cuts made in the drive to “efficiency” would be a false efficiency.
A) an example is where you use, (and I agree with you), Saturday delivery. I will also throw in that the USPS has tried to cut that and also cut delivery to some smaller routes. It has also tried to cut their offices/ staff / other costs in smaller towns and go to more effficient regional or multi-town offices which is what is done with some school districts.
But, the elected representatives of the people have prevented the post office from making these moves to efficiency.
The post office, if privatized, would be able to do that but (perhaps wrongly) the populace values the service and thus would view it as a cost to them if it was cut. So, would a privatization also include a prohibition on cutting that? If so, where would privatization help?
Another real example of this from the days when the USPS was a client of mine...they started their own air delivery next day service. Planes, distribution hubs etc. It was beating the pants off of FedEx and UPS. FedEx appealed to their congressman who then said that the government should not compete with “private industry” and made USPS sell all of the planes and so on and do contracts with “private industry” to supply the USPS with overnight, second day, third day services. Guess what. The rates went up and FedEx/ UPS turned a competitor into a captive customer. That is why so many post offices have a FedEx box. Letting the fox into the hen coop.
2) A government (or in this case a quasi governmental) entity serves the need of the people while a company serves the need of the capital owners.
Thus, a privatization would have to result in approximately a 25% increase in efficiency. That is a number of increased productivity I have never heard of in my experience.
The reason is that operations like the post office are non-profit whereas a corporation is for profit. So, a 20% profit margin plus 5% for a cushion to make it better than even that you would make the switch and you get to an impossible arithmetic to justify doing it.
If you want to see real world on why privatization is actually a bad idea for public goods and services look at just three of the examples in transportation (which is essentially what the post office is)...the huge highway in Ontario with all of the crashes that it is an endless battle on getting it right, the bridge that fell in Italy killing many, or the North Carolina road system which was supposed to be in lieu of gas taxes to pay for the highways and they have high gas taxes still and are stuck with billions in repairs that the taxpayers will have to pay for.
Don’t forget that the Roman Empire worked because they realized that a sanitation system and a road/transport system would allow an empire to exist so the government provided that and the Empire thrived.
There are many reasons that the US Empire is failing but I would hate to see us hasten it by making choices of changes to commonly needed systems for the false god reasons.
Oh, and digitizing mail....Don’t forget that one of the horrors of the pandemic is the number of school children in NYC (and elsewhere) who don’t have online access so that they can’t participate in schooling from home while schools are closed. And, anyone seeing the mail (a reason not to use gmail) of a private individual especially on a mass basis is frightening from privacy issues basis.
« If I knew what I was doing, I’d be doing it right now »
-Jon Mandel
Bookmarks